Shwetambar vs Digambar: how the two Jain traditions differ

Shwetambar and Digambar Jains compared: monastic dress, the Agam scriptures, liberation of women, the kevali, Mahavir's life and how the split came about.

Jainism has two great traditions, the Shwetambar (Śvetāmbara) and the Digambar (Digambara). Both follow the teaching of Mahavir, the twenty-fourth Tirthankar. Both honour the same five supreme beings in the Navkar Mantra, and both hold the same account of the soul, karma and liberation. They part ways on a small number of questions that matter a great deal in practice: whether a monk may wear clothes, which scriptures are authentic, whether a woman can reach liberation, whether an omniscient being eats, and several details of Mahavir’s own life (Dundas 2002; Jaini 1979).

This article sets out those differences as each tradition states them, with the scholarship behind them. Where the two disagree, it gives both views and does not take a side.

In short. Digambar monks renounce all clothing, as Mahavir did. Shwetambar monks and nuns wear white. Digambars hold that the original Agam scriptures are lost and that liberation needs a male body. Shwetambars preserve a canon of 45 texts (32 for the Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi) and teach that women can be liberated. The core doctrine, from the Navkar Mantra to the theory of karma, is shared.

Differences at a glance

QuestionShwetambarDigambar
Monastic dressMonks and nuns wear plain white clothMonks (muni) renounce all clothing. Nuns (aryika) wear one white sari
What a monk carriesA woollen whisk (rajoharan), alms bowls (patra) and a mouth cloth (muhpatti)A peacock-feather whisk (pinchhi) and a water pot (kamandal)
How monks eatAlms are collected in bowls and eaten at the lodging (upashray)Once a day, standing, from the cupped hands
Scripture45 Agams (Murtipujak) or 32 (Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi), written down at Valabhi in the 5th century CEThe original Agams are lost. The Shatkhandagam, the Kashaypahud and later teachers’ works take their place
Women and liberationA woman can attain liberationLiberation needs a male body
Does a kevali eat?YesNo
Mallinath, 19th TirthankarA woman, MalliA man
Dreams of a Tirthankar’s motherFourteenSixteen
Mahavir’s conceptionMoved from Devananda’s womb to Trishala’sConceived by Trishala; the transfer is rejected
Mahavir’s marriageMarried Yashoda and had a daughterNever married
How a Tirthankar teachesIn speech, in ArdhamagadhiThrough a divine sound (divya dhvani)
Images of the JinasShown with a lower garment, adorned in worship (Murtipujak)Nude and unadorned, with downcast eyes
Rainy-season festivalParyushan, eight daysDas Lakshan Parva, ten days

Each row is explained below, with its sources.

What the names mean

Digambar joins the Sanskrit dik (the directions of space) and ambara (garment): “clothed by the directions”, usually translated “sky-clad”. Shwetambar joins śveta (white) and ambara: “white-clad”. Both names describe monks. Lay Jains of either tradition dress like their neighbours (Dundas 2002).

The Shwetambar tradition later divided over image worship. On this site, Shwetambar means the image-worshipping Murtipujak (Deravasi) tradition, while the Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi traditions, which are Shwetambar in origin but do not worship images, have their own pages. Digambar lyrics are gathered separately.

How the two traditions separated

Each tradition tells the story of the split, and each makes the other the innovator.

The Digambar account

A twelve-year famine struck Magadha. Acharya Bhadrabahu, the last monk to know the whole of the scripture, led a large group of monks south to Karnataka; tradition holds that the emperor Chandragupta Maurya went with him and died at Shravanabelagola. The monks who stayed in the north under Sthulabhadra began to wear cloth during the famine. When the southern monks returned, they found the northern community clothed and refused to accept it (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002). Britannica notes that the earliest written Digambar version of this story dates from the 10th century CE, although it places the events in the 4th century BCE (Britannica, "Digambara").

The Shwetambar account

Shwetambar commentaries on the Avashyak Sutra trace the Digambars to a monk named Shivabhuti, who is said to have abandoned his robe and insisted on nudity 609 years after Mahavir’s liberation, which tradition equates with 82 CE. His followers are called the Botika (Dundas 2002; Wikipedia, "Jain schools and branches").

What historians conclude

Scholars read both stories as later explanations of a separation that was gradual, not a single event (Britannica, "Digambara"; Dundas 2002). The oldest texts show that clothed and unclothed practice existed side by side from early on. The Shwetambar Acharang Sutra itself says Mahavir kept a robe for a little over a year after renouncing the world and then went naked (Jacobi 1884, Acharang 1.8.1). The Uttaradhyayan Sutra records a meeting between Keshi, a monk in the line of Parshvanath, and Gautam, Mahavir’s chief disciple, at which they discuss why Parshvanath’s monks wore garments while Mahavir’s went without (Jacobi 1895, Uttaradhyayan 23).

The break became final over scripture. When the Shwetambar canon was fixed at Valabhi in the 5th century CE, the Digambars took no part and did not accept it (Dundas 2002). A third group, the Yapaniya, had naked monks but agreed with the Shwetambars that women can be liberated and that a kevali eats. It is known from inscriptions and texts in Karnataka and later disappeared (Jaini 1991; Dundas 2002).

  • Mahavir's sangh6th or 5th century BCE

    • Shwetambar"White-clad"

      • MurtipujakWorship images in temples (derasar). Gacchas such as Tapa and Kharatar

      • Lonka gaccha15th century; rejected image worship

        • Sthanakvasi17th century; no image worship, muhpatti worn over the mouth

          • Terapanth1760, Acharya Bhikshu; one acharya leads the order

    • Digambar"Sky-clad"

      • BispanthAccepts the bhattaraks; worship with flowers, fruit and lamps

      • Terapanth17th century; rejected the bhattaraks and offerings of fresh flowers and fruit. Not related to the Shwetambar Terapanth

      • TaranpanthTaran Svami, around 1500; venerates scripture, not images

      • Kanji Svami movement20th century; centred on Kundakunda's Samaysar

    • YapaniyaExtinct. Naked monks, yet held that women can be liberated and that a kevali eats

The main branches of the Jain tradition, simplified. Dates are those usually given in the sources below; sub-traditions are not ranked by size.

Scripture: the question of the Agam

Both traditions agree on how scripture began. Mahavir’s teaching was arranged by his chief disciples, the ganadhar, into twelve Angs (aṅga, “limbs”). The twelfth, the Drishtivad, contained the fourteen Purvas, the oldest layer of teaching. Both agree that the Drishtivad has been lost (Dundas 2002; Wikipedia, "Jain Agamas"). They disagree about the other eleven.

The Shwetambar canon

Shwetambar tradition records a series of councils that recovered and recited the scriptures as memory failed: at Pataliputra, traditionally in the 4th or 3rd century BCE; at Mathura and Valabhi in the early 4th century CE; and finally at Valabhi under Devarddhigani Kshamashraman, 980 or 993 years after Mahavir’s liberation (453 or 466 CE), when the texts were written down (Dundas 2002; Wikipedia, "Jain Agamas"). The language of the canon is Ardhamagadhi Prakrit.

Murtipujak Shwetambars count 45 Agams. The Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi accept 32, leaving out the ten Prakirnaks and three further texts, the Mahanishith, the Jitkalp and the Pindniryukti (Dundas 2002; Wikipedia, "Jain Agamas").

Shwetambar Murtipujak 45 Agams

  • 11 Ang
  • 12 Upang
  • 10 Prakirnak
  • 6 Chhed sutra
  • 4 Mul sutra
  • 2 Chulika sutra

Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi 32 Agams

  • 11 Ang
  • 12 Upang
  • 4 Chhed sutra
  • 4 Mul sutra
  • 1 Avashyak

Digambar Original Angs held lost

  • 12 Ang, held lost; parts of the twelfth survive in the Shatkhandagam and Kashaypahud
One square is one text. The twelfth Ang, the Drishtivad, is counted as lost by every tradition and is not in the 45 or the 32. Lists of the Chhed and Mul sutras differ slightly between Shwetambar groups.

Digambar scripture

Digambars hold that the Angs and the Purvas were gradually forgotten, and they do not accept the Shwetambar canon as authentic. In their tradition, Acharya Dharasena, living in a cave at Girnar, taught what he remembered of the Purvas to two monks, Pushpadant and Bhutabali, who composed the Shatkhandagam (“scripture in six parts”). Another teacher, Gunadhar, composed the Kashaypahud on the passions. Both are in Jain Shauraseni Prakrit, are usually dated to the first centuries CE, and are read with the 9th-century Dhavala and Jayadhavala commentaries of Virasena and his pupil Jinasena. Digambars celebrate the completion of the Shatkhandagam as Shrut Panchami (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002).

Alongside these, Digambars treat a body of later works as authoritative, arranged in four anuyog (“expositions”): narrative (such as Jinasena’s Adipuran), cosmology and karma (such as Nemichandra’s Gommatsar), conduct (such as the Mulachar and Samantabhadra’s Ratnakarand Shravakachar) and philosophy (such as the works of Kundakunda, including the Samaysar and Pravachansar) (Jaini 1979; Wikipedia, "Jain Agamas").

A text both accept

Umaswati’s Tattvarth Sutra, a Sanskrit summary of the whole of Jain doctrine, is accepted by both traditions, with small differences in wording and numbering. Shwetambars read it with the Bhashya they regard as Umaswati’s own commentary; Digambars read it with Pujyapad’s Sarvarthasiddhi (Umasvati 1994). Its first sutra is common ground for every Jain: right faith, right knowledge and right conduct together are the path to liberation.

Theological differences

Clothing and renunciation

The fifth great vow is aparigraha, non-possession. For Digambars, a cloth is a possession: it has to be obtained, washed and guarded, it harms the small beings that live in it, and it shows that the body’s needs still rule. A monk who wears one has not renounced completely, and so cannot reach the highest stages of the path (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002).

Shwetambars answer from the Tattvarth Sutra, which defines possession as attachment (mūrcchā) (Umasvati 1994). A robe kept only to protect life and modesty, without attachment, is not possession. Shwetambar texts accept that Mahavir went naked and recognise nudity as a valid path (jinakalpa), but hold that it ceased with Jambu, the last person to attain omniscience in this age. Since then the norm has been the path of the elders (sthavirakalpa), with robes and bowls (Dundas 2002; Jaini 1979).

Can a woman attain liberation?

This question, strī-mukti, divides the traditions most sharply. Digambar teachers argue that a woman cannot go naked, so she cannot complete renunciation, and they give further arguments about her body and nature; a woman must first be reborn as a man. Digambar nuns (aryika) are honoured and can progress far, but not to liberation in that life (Jaini 1991).

Shwetambars hold that liberation depends on the soul’s inner state, not on the body. They point to Malli, the nineteenth Tirthankar, whom they hold to have been a woman, and to Marudevi, the mother of Rishabh, whom they count as the first soul of this age to be liberated. The Yapaniya teacher Shakatayana wrote a treatise in defence of women’s liberation, translated with its Digambar replies by Padmanabh Jaini (Jaini 1991). In Shwetambar orders today, nuns greatly outnumber monks (Dundas 2002).

Does a kevali eat?

A kevali has destroyed the four destructive (ghāti) karmas and is omniscient, but still lives in a body until death. Digambars hold that such a being has infinite bliss and feels no hunger, since hunger is a form of suffering and eating a form of desire; a kevali’s body is sustained without food. Shwetambars reply that the four non-destructive (aghāti) karmas, including the karma that brings feeling, still act on a kevali’s body, so it needs food, and that eating without desire takes nothing from omniscience. This debate, kevali-bhukti, was argued alongside the debate on women (Jaini 1991; Jaini 1979).

The life of Mahavir

The Shwetambar Kalpa Sutra, which Murtipujak communities read aloud during Paryushan, tells that Mahavir was first conceived by a Brahmin woman, Devananda, and that the god Indra had the embryo moved to the womb of the Kshatriya queen Trishala. It describes the fourteen dreams Trishala saw, and names Mahavir’s wife, Yashoda, and their daughter (Jacobi 1884, Kalpa Sutra). Digambars reject the transfer of the embryo, count sixteen dreams and hold that Mahavir never married (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002). The traditions also differ on when he gave up clothes: Shwetambars after thirteen months, as the Acharang says; Digambars at the moment of renunciation.

How a Tirthankar teaches

For Shwetambars, a Tirthankar preaches in Ardhamagadhi, which every listener, human or animal, understands in their own language. For Digambars, an omniscient being does not speak as people do: a divine sound (divya dhvani) without syllables comes forth, and the ganadhar render it into words (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002).

Practice: monks, temples and festivals

Monastic life

A Digambar muni keeps twenty-eight primary rules (mūlaguṇa). Among them: he goes naked, pulls out his hair by hand (keśa-loñca) and eats once a day, standing, from his cupped hands . He carries only a peacock-feather whisk for gently moving small creatures out of the way, and a water pot . Men on the way to full renunciation may live as a kṣullaka with two cloths or an ailaka with a loincloth only (Jaini 1979; Dundas 2002).

Shwetambar monks and nuns wear white cloth , collect food in bowls from several households and carry a woollen whisk (rajoharan) . Murtipujak monks hold the mouth cloth (muhpatti) in the hand while speaking; Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi monks and nuns wear it tied over the mouth (Cort 2001; Dundas 2002). In every tradition, monastics walk barefoot, use no vehicles and keep the five great vows.

Images and worship

Digambar images of the Jinas are nude and unadorned, with downcast eyes. Murtipujak Shwetambar images are carved with a lower garment and, in daily worship, are often given inlaid eyes and decorated with ornaments, an adornment called āṅgī (Cort 2001; Dundas 2002). Within the Digambar tradition, the Bispanth make offerings of flowers, fruit and lamps, while the Digambar Terapanth reject the authority of the bhattaraks and do not offer fresh flowers or fruit (Wiley 2004).

Some groups do not worship images at all: the Sthanakvasi and Terapanthi among Shwetambars, and the Taranpanth among Digambars, who honour scripture instead (Wiley 2004; Wikipedia, "Jain schools and branches").

Festivals

The great observance of the rainy season falls in the month of Bhadrapad in both traditions. Shwetambars keep Paryushan for eight days, ending with Samvatsari, the annual rite of repentance (pratikraman); Murtipujak communities read the Kalpa Sutra during it. Digambars keep Das Lakshan Parva for ten days, one for each of the ten virtues listed in the ninth chapter of the Tattvarth Sutra: forbearance, humility, straightforwardness, purity, truthfulness, restraint, austerity, renunciation, non-possession and celibacy. A chapter of the Tattvarth Sutra is commonly read on each day (Dundas 2002; Umasvati 1994).

Both end by asking forgiveness of every living being: Micchāmi dukkaḍaṃ among Shwetambars, Kshamavani among Digambars. The Prakrit verse Khamemi Savve Jiva belongs to this moment.

Traditions within each

Neither tradition is uniform. Among Shwetambars, the Murtipujak are organised in monastic lineages (gaccha) such as the Tapa and the Kharatar. In the 15th century, the layman Lonka Shah rejected image worship; from his movement came the Sthanakvasi in the 17th century, and from the Sthanakvasi came the Terapanth, founded by Acharya Bhikshu in 1760 and led by a single acharya (Dundas 2002; Wiley 2004).

Among Digambars, the main divisions are the Bispanth and the Terapanth, the Taranpanth founded by Taran Svami around 1500, and the 20th-century movement of Kanji Svami, which centres on Kundakunda’s Samaysar (Wiley 2004; Dundas 2002).

The name Terapanth is used by two unrelated groups, one Shwetambar and one Digambar. The Terapanthi lyrics on this site belong to the Shwetambar Terapanth.

What both traditions share

The differences are real and have been argued for centuries, but they sit on a large shared foundation (Long 2009; Dundas 2002):

  • The same salutation. The Navkar Mantra (Namokar Mantra) is recited by every Jain. Shwetambars add a four-line chulika stating its fruit, and Digambars usually begin each line with Ṇamo. The Chattari Mangalam is also shared.
  • The same Tirthankars. Both honour the same twenty-four Tirthankars of this age, from Rishabh to Mahavir, and the same cosmology of rising and falling time cycles.
  • The same path. Right faith, right knowledge and right conduct; the same categories of reality (tattva); the same theory of karma binding to the soul and being shed (Umasvati 1994).
  • The same ethics. Non-violence (ahiṃsā) above all, the five vows in their monastic and lay forms, and the many-sided view of truth (anekāntavāda).
  • The same holy places. Sammed Shikhar, where twenty Tirthankars attained liberation, and Girnar are sacred to both.

Even the closing blessing shows how close they remain. Digambars recite maṅgalaṃ bhagavān vīro maṅgalaṃ gautamo gaṇī, maṅgalaṃ kundakundāryo jainadharmo ‘stu maṅgalam, naming Mahavir, Gautam and Kundakunda. Shwetambars recite the same verse with Sthulabhadra in place of Kundakunda (Wikipedia, "Kundakunda").

Lyrics from these traditions

Lyrics mentioned in this article

Sources and further reading

Citations in the text, such as (Dundas 2002), link to the full entry below. Page numbers vary between editions, so primary texts are cited by their own chapter and section numbers.

  1. "Digambara." Encyclopaedia Britannica.
  2. John E. Cort. 2001. Jains in the World: Religious Values and Ideology in India. New York: Oxford University Press. Shwetambar Murtipujak monastic and temple practice, from fieldwork in Gujarat.
  3. Paul Dundas. 2002. The Jains. 2nd edition. Library of Religious Beliefs and Practices. London and New York: Routledge. ISBN 9780415266062. The standard academic survey. Covers the origin accounts, the councils and canon, the women and kevali debates, and the sub-traditions.
  4. 1884. Jaina Sutras, Part I: The Akaranga Sutra and The Kalpa Sutra. Translated by Hermann Jacobi. Sacred Books of the East, vol. 22. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Shwetambar canonical sources for Mahavir's renunciation, conception, dreams and family.
  5. 1895. Jaina Sutras, Part II: The Uttaradhyayana Sutra and The Sutrakritanga Sutra. Translated by Hermann Jacobi. Sacred Books of the East, vol. 45. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Lecture 23 records the dialogue of Keshi and Gautam on clothed and unclothed monks.
  6. Padmanabh S. Jaini. 1979. The Jaina Path of Purification. Berkeley: University of California Press. Doctrine and practice in both traditions, including Digambar scripture and monastic rules.
  7. Padmanabh S. Jaini. 1991. Gender and Salvation: Jaina Debates on the Spiritual Liberation of Women. Berkeley: University of California Press. Publisher page Translates the classical Digambar, Shwetambar and Yapaniya arguments on the liberation of women and on whether a kevali eats.
  8. Jeffery D. Long. 2009. Jainism: An Introduction. London: I.B. Tauris. Introduction to shared Jain doctrine and to the sectarian divisions.
  9. Umasvati. 1994. That Which Is: Tattvartha Sutra. Translated by Nathmal Tatia. Sacred Literature Series. San Francisco: HarperCollins. ISBN 0060689854. The one systematic text both traditions accept, translated with the Shwetambar Bhashya and the Digambar Sarvarthasiddhi commentaries.
  10. "Jain Agamas." Wikipedia.
  11. "Jain schools and branches." Wikipedia.
  12. "Kundakunda." Wikipedia.
  13. Kristi L. Wiley. 2004. Historical Dictionary of Jainism. Historical Dictionaries of Religions, Philosophies, and Movements. Lanham, Maryland: Scarecrow Press. Entries on each sub-tradition, its founder and its date.

This article is awaiting review by a second reader against the sources listed. Corrections are welcome.